Top 16 Contestants
Front Row, L-R Kate Fine (LaPorte County) Samantha Markham (Elkhart County) 3rd Runner-Up: Caleigh Cates (Gibson County) 1st Runner-Up: Ellie Acra (Decatur County) Miss Indiana State Fair 2023, Claire Bishop (Hancock County) 2nd Runner-Up: Bre Davis (Owen County) 4th Runner-Up: Mya Miller (Martin County) Miss Congeniality: Grace McCarty (Johnson County, Top 16) Grace Cloud (Tipton County, Top 10)
Second Row, L-R Eliana Delph, Madison County (Top 16) Gracie Skirvin, Monroe County (Top 10) Kiana Allshouse, Steuben County (Top 16) Marnie Schwartzkopf, Bartholomew County (Top 10) Markie Lance, Warrick County (Top 16) Allysen Armstrong, Crawford County (Top 16) Melanie Gebhart, Whitley County (Top 16)